Another Landmark Victory Against Travelers Insurance

State court ruled CGL policy exclusion was too ambiguous to enforce

The law firm of Pillsbury & Coleman LLP prevailed again in ongoing litigation against Traveler’s Insurance on behalf of a commercial policyholder. A California state court ruling, the first of its kind, declared that Travelers could not rely on a vague policy exclusion to shirk its duty to defend its insured.

There have been several key victories in this case. This latest ruling has positive implications for other businesses in disputes with their insurers over commercial general liability policies. The court ruled that residential exclusions -- which are standard in virtually every CGL policy issued by Travelers -- are too broad and ambiguous.

We held Travelers and its negligent adjuster accountable

Pillsbury & Coleman LLP regularly represents commercial clients in insurance coverage litigation in the Bay Area and statewide. We are commonly sought out by business law attorneys and corporate counsel who realize they need outside expertise in insurance law.

Tucker v. The Travelers Indemnity Co. reached the California Court of Appeals before it was ultimately decided in the Superior Court of San Francisco County in favor of our client. Attorney Terry Coleman represented Don Tucker and Martin Aguilar (dba Don Tucker & Son), a construction contractor who was sued for a personal injury accident at a job site. Travelers declined to defend Tucker, which left him exposed to an $18.5 million judgment.

We sued Travelers for breach of contract, namely failure in its legal duty to defend an insured. The complaint, filed in state court, also named the insurance adjuster as a defendant. The adjuster had told Mr. Tucker that his business was not covered for the injury because of a “full residential exclusion” in his policy. Yet the adjuster knew or should have known there was no such exclusion. As a result of the material misrepresentation, Mr. Tucker spent thousands of dollars on additional unnecessary insurance in an effort to protect his enterprise.

Insurance adjusters can be sued individually for misrepresentations

This case was an important affirmation of a California Court of Appeals decision (Bock v. Hansen) that insurance adjusters can be individually liable for misrepresentation or other forms of fraud. Previously, adjusters were considered immune as third parties to the contract between insurer and insured.

For policyholders, the Bock and Tucker rulings are another tool in the bag to hold insurance companies and their representatives accountable for bad faith insurance practices. Adjusters cannot hide behind the insurance companies, and vice versa.

Policy exclusion was ambiguous

By defeating the defense motion to remove the adjuster from the lawsuit, we prevented Travelers from removing the case to federal court on the premise of diversity jurisdiction. After the Court of Appeals remanded the case to Superior Court, we prevailed in the underlying action against Travelers. The state court granted in entirety our motion for summary adjudication.

The court declared that the residential exclusion in the CGL policy was ambiguous – in essence, unenforceable. In other words, the supposed exclusion did relieve Travelers of its duty to defend, and it must cover the underlying $18.5 judgment that resulted from its bad faith refusal.

This is a huge win, not just for our client, but because Travelers has used a similar policy exclusion in most of its CGL underwriting. Those exclusions are now susceptible to legal challenge.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Our Attorneys

Our Insurance Lawyers Can Help

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

  • American Board of Trial Advocates
    American Board of Trial Advocates A prestigious national association of experienced trial lawyers and judges. Membership is by exclusive invitation only. All members shall have completed 10 civil jury trials to jury verdict or hung jury as lead counsel.
  • Best Lawyers
    Best Lawyers The oldest and most respected peer-review publication in the legal profession. A listing in Best Lawyers is widely regarded by both clients and legal professionals as a significant honor, conferred on a lawyer by his or her peers.
  • AV | PeerReviewRated | Martindale-Hubbell | For Ethical Standards and Legal Ability
    Martindale-Hubbell Peer Review Ratings An objective peer review rating indicator of a lawyer's high ethical standards and professional ability, generated from evaluations of lawyers by other members of the bar and the judiciary. Pillsbury & Coleman founding partner Philip L. Pillsbury Jr. is rated “AV Preeminent.”
  • Super Lawyers
    Super Lawyers A peer-review rating service of outstanding lawyers from more than 70 practice areas who have attained a high-degree of peer recognition and professional achievement.
  • Best Lawyers | Best Law Firms | U.S.News & World Report | 2019
    Best Lawyers Best Law Firms U.S. News 2019
  • American Association for Justice | Formerly the Association of Trial Lawyers of America (ATLA)
    American Association for Justice (AAJ) Founded in 1946, AAJ is the world’s largest trial bar and supports the work of attorneys to ensure that injured plaintiffs can obtain justice.
  • American College of Coverage Counsel
    American College of Coverage and Extracontractual Counsel Composed of preeminent insurance coverage counsel in the United States and Canada, representing the interests of both insurers and policyholders. The minimum membership requirement is the practice of insurance law for at least fifteen consecutive years.
  • Association of Business Trial Lawyers | abtl
    Association of Business Trial Lawyers Founded in 1972, ABTL is dedicated to connecting litigators and judges to address issues important to trial lawyers.
  • Consumer Attorneys of California
    Consumer Attorneys of California The only California-wide unified trial bar for plaintiffs lawyers who represent consumers harmed by powerful foes such as insurance companies, pharmaceutical companies, automobile manufacturers and banks.
  • SFTLA | San Francisco Trial Lawyers Association
    San Francisco Trial Lawyers Association For over 60 years, this prestigious bar association has educated and trained trial lawyers and supported and passed critical legislation to protect and advance individuals’ rights.
  • United Policyholders | Empowering the Insured
    United Policyholders A non-profit group dedicated to providing trustworthy and useful information and an effective voice for insurance consumers in all 50 states.
  • America's Top 100 High Stakes Litigators | 2018 | Top 100
    ACCEC | American College of Coverage and Extracontractual Counsel | Fellow